Books Like A Series of Unfortunate Events, Sorted 4 Ways
October 20, 2026

A kid who loved A Series of Unfortunate Events didn’t love A Series of Unfortunate Events. They loved one of four things inside it, and until you know which one, every list you find is a coin flip.
I learned that the expensive way. Cole finished the thirteenth book on a Tuesday night, came downstairs holding it like a brick, and asked what was next. I gave him the famous one. The one every librarian, every list, every relative who means well hands you. He brought it back four days later and said it was fine.
Fine. Nine-year-olds do not say “fine” about books they like.
So I asked him what he actually loved about Snicket, which is a question I should have led with. He didn’t say the orphans. He didn’t say Count Olaf. He said he liked that the guy writing it kept telling him to put the book down and go read something cheerful.
That’s not a plot. That’s a narrator. And once I knew that, finding the next book took about ten minutes.
Here’s the thing those thirteen books do that makes this so slippery. They’re doing four jobs at once, and a kid will latch onto one and barely notice the other three:
- a narrator who interrupts, warns you off, and refuses to cheer up
- the vocabulary games — “a word which here means” — and the way he talks straight at you
- the puzzle layer: the codes, the initials, the secret organization you’re not supposed to understand yet
- clever kids outlasting adults who are either useless or actively against them
Four different books. Four different shelves. Pick the wrong one and you get “fine.”
If they loved the narrator
This is Cole’s shelf, and in my experience it’s the most common one and the least often guessed.
The Willoughbys is the closest thing to a tonal match I’ve found. Four children work out that the best life available to them is the one orphans get in books, so they start trying to arrange it. Their parents are simultaneously trying to get rid of them. Lois Lowry wrote it completely straight, as a parody of the whole genre, with a glossary in the back that defines words the way an unimpressed adult would. It’s short. It’s mean in the way Snicket is mean, which is to say it’s on the kids’ side the entire time.
A Tale Dark & Grimm goes harder. Hansel and Gretel walk out of their story and through eight other Grimm tales — the real ones, with the parts your bedtime version dropped. What makes it a Snicket book is the narrator, who stops the action to say, in effect, this next bit is horrible, send the little ones out.
He means it, too — there’s a scene early on that I’m not going to describe here, and I’d tell any parent to read the first twenty pages themselves before handing it over. Luke isn’t getting this one for a few years. Cole took it like a kid who’d been waiting for somebody to stop protecting him.
If they loved the words
Snicket’s other signature move is talking to you directly and stopping mid-sentence to define something. A kid who loved that loved the voice in the room, not the gloom.
The Tale of Despereaux is the gentlest landing on this page and the one I’d reach for first for a younger reader. A very small mouse who loves stories too much falls for a princess, which his family regards as a scandal. Kate DiCamillo narrates it the whole way — calls you “dear reader,” pauses to explain a word, occasionally asks whether you’d have been braver. It won the Newbery in 2004. It is also, fair warning, sadder than its cover suggests.
The Phantom Tollbooth is the upper end of the same shelf. A boy with nothing to do drives through a tollbooth that shows up in his bedroom and lands in a kingdom where Words and Numbers have fallen out. Almost everything in it is a pun played perfectly straight — a watchdog who is a dog with a watch in him, a banquet where you eat your own words.
That’s the catch. If the reader isn’t old enough to hear the joke, the book just reads like a strange dream, and they’ll put it down. Cole got it at nine. I’d have wasted it on him at seven.
If they loved the puzzle
Some kids aren’t reading Snicket for the voice at all. They’re reading it for V.F.D. — the initials, the spyglass, the sense that there’s a second book hidden behind the first one.
The Mysterious Benedict Society is built for that kid. Four children answer a newspaper ad, sit a series of tests that are genuinely strange, and get sent into a school that’s quietly broadcasting something. The tests are printed on the page, and you get to sit them too. The book doesn’t cheat.
It’s around five hundred pages, which is either the selling point or the problem, depending on your reader.
Escape from Mr. Lemoncello’s Library is the same itch at a quarter of the weight. Twelve kids win an overnight stay in a new library designed by a man who makes board games. Morning comes, the doors don’t open, and the way out is a puzzle built into the building itself — rebuses, riddles hidden in book spines, clues sitting in the Dewey numbers, and a lot of running.
It’s warmer than Snicket and nobody is ever really in trouble, which for some kids is a feature. Luke can follow this one read aloud right now at seven, and he gets the rebuses before I do, which he has mentioned more than once.
If they loved watching the grown-ups lose
The fourth thing Snicket sells is simple and it is powerful: the adults are useless, and the children are not.
Matilda is the purest version of it in print. A girl who taught herself to read at four lives with parents who find her inconvenient and attends a school run by a woman who throws children by the hair. Nobody comes to help. Matilda sorts it out herself, with books and patience and one very good trick.
Dahl is blunt about the adults in a way most modern middle grade won’t risk anymore, and kids feel the difference immediately. This one also drops in age better than anything else on this page — a seven-year-old can take it as a read-aloud.
Holes is the version for the older reader. A boy who didn’t do it gets sent to a camp in the desert, where the inmates dig one hole every day, five feet by five feet, and the warden won’t say what she’s looking for. Three separate timelines run through it, generations apart, and when they meet you can hear the whole thing lock.
It won the Newbery and the National Book Award, and it’s the rare kid-versus-useless-adults book where the adults are genuinely frightening. One of the historical strands turns on a Black man being murdered by a white mob for kissing a white woman. I’d put the whole book at ten and up, and I’d know my kid first.
The one everybody recommends
The Name of This Book Is Secret, by “Pseudonymous Bosch.”
I understand why it’s always the answer. A narrator with a fake name who begs you not to keep reading, footnotes, redacted details, a conspiracy — on paper it’s Snicket to the letter, and plenty of kids do love it.
But it copies the device without the weight underneath. The Baudelaires are grieving and in actual danger, and Snicket’s jokes are what a person does when things are genuinely bad. Bosch’s narrator is doing a bit. The reluctance is a gag rather than a mood, and the kid who loved Snicket for the feeling — that someone sad was looking after them while telling them a hard story — tends to notice the difference around chapter four and drift off.
That’s not a bad book. It’s the right recommendation for a kid who loved the format and a miss for the kid who loved the tone, and almost nobody asks which one they’ve got.
How to actually hand it over
Don’t ask them what they want to read next. They don’t know; that’s why you’re here.
Ask what the best part was. Not the favourite book in the series, not the favourite character — the best part. Then shut up and let them talk, because the answer is usually in the first thirty seconds and it’s usually not what you expected. Cole told me his favourite bit was a man telling him to stop reading. I’d have guessed Olaf.
Then leave the book somewhere and walk away. Kitchen table, foot of the bed, on top of the laundry they’re supposed to be putting away, passenger seat of the truck. Mention nothing. If you stand there watching, you’ve turned it into homework, and I have never once seen that work.
And if it comes back “fine” — go ask the question again. You picked the wrong one of the four, that’s all. I’ve done it. The second guess is nearly always right, because by then you’ve stopped guessing.
If the kid you have in mind is less a Snicket reader and more a kid who won’t read at all, that’s a different problem with a different fix, and I wrote it up here. And if you’re the one still reading these out loud rather than handing them over — which is how they went in this house — here’s whether the series actually holds up as a read-aloud, where to start, and how far in it’s worth committing.